Category Archives: Appendices

An Update on JOA Negotiations

We are still going back and forth with Park Board staff on the Joint Operating Agreement (JOA). The CCAs believe that we are moving in a positive direction. As individual CCAs, we have specifics that we need to work through with the Park Board to ensure that the JOA works for our respective communities.

The update is that the dialogue continues between the CCAs and Park Board staff. We appreciate that they are working with us to resolve the issues we have identified.

We also want to acknowledge our community members for your ongoing support. We know that you want to see us achieve a JOA that works for each of our unique neighbourhoods. Your continued words, e-mails and calls give us the energy to keep fighting for what we need in the JOA. Thank you.

We remain cautiously hopeful that we are close to having a JOA that we can recommend to our respective boards. We will update when we have news to share.

Media Statement from Hastings Community Association

Statement attributable to Sherry Breshears, President, Hastings Community Association

 

Hastings Community Association Board encouraged by JOA progress

The Hastings Community Association (HCA) Board is encouraged by the Park Board’s recent efforts to work with CCAs in addressing three key issues identified in the current draft of the Joint Operating Agreement (JOA). However, the Board did not vote on the JOA at their January 24, 2018 meeting. The HCA Board requires reasonable time to review the proposed draft language placed in context with the entire appendix, consult our legal counsel, and confer with our partners – Killarney Community Centre Society and Kerrisdale Community Centre Society.

The proposed changes were provided to the CCAs by Park Board staff just hours before the HCA Board meeting, and the language and placement in the JOA are still being worked through between the CCAs and the Park Board.

The three CCAs have approached the long and difficult negotiation process with the Park Board as partners, and we will continue to support one another, going forward. At this stage of the process, each of us must now turn our attention inward and support our respective boards in making decisions based on the needs of our individual CCAs and communities.

-END-

 

Killarney Community Centre Society (KCCS) Media Statement

Statement attributable to Ainslie Kwan, Past President KCCS

Killarney Community Centre Society Board Defers Final Board Vote
to Review New JOA Language

The Killarney Community Centre Society Board of Directors is enthusiastic and optimistic about the language revisions we received throughout the day and into the evening of January 23, 2018 from the Park Board for the Joint Operating Agreement (JOA).

We have made the decision to respectfully defer the final board vote on the JOA until we have had reasonable time to review the proposed draft language placed in context with the entire appendix, consult our legal counsel, and confer with our partners Hastings Community Association and Kerrisdale Community Centre Society.

-END-

Why We Continue to Fight for Our Communities

The three changes we want made to the JOA are reasonable. And they have real world applications for our CCAs and for other CCAs who are closely monitoring this situation. You see, if the Park Board will work with us and make these straightforward changes – all CCAs will have the ability to have these changes made too.

A current situation that is facing Killarney Community Centre Society is that they are in the process of getting a Seniors’ Centre. This is a great thing for their community. The Killarney Community Centre Society and its members have been working towards this for years. The CCA has worked hard to raise a substantial amount of money through grants and other means – we’re talking $1.5 million – most of which is earmarked to go to the Seniors’ Centre (especially to run the hot lunch program, which is a highly anticipated initiative). It is a substantial contribution that they are making to the Seniors’ Centre in support of what has come from the City of Vancouver.

Right now, the way the JOA is worded, when the Seniors’ Centre is built, the Park Board will have the ability to decide that the Killarney Community Centre Society should not run the Seniors’ Centre in partnership with them. All they need to show is that they have “reasonable concerns” – there is no defined criteria for what “reasonable concerns” means. Killarney could be doing something that makes complete sense in the community and if the Park Board doesn’t agree with it, misunderstands what they are doing, or decides to punish Killarney Community Centre Society for continuing to be a strong, vocal voice that criticizes the Park Board, they can deny them access to the Seniors’ Centre. And – the concerns that the Park Board can use in a situation like this could have happened PRIOR to this agreement being signed. The Park Board could go back years to find something that they can then say causes them “reasonable concerns.”

This provides the Park Board with unchecked power, especially given that the Seniors’ Centre is currently being built and that Killarney is a strong, outspoken voice for the community, that criticizes the Park Board when they feel that it is required.

It is important to have this type of clause in an agreement. We support that. We just want it to be clearly defined so that it can’t be applied because of a misunderstanding, miscommunication, misperception or an abuse of power. We want to work with the Park Board staff to come up with language that defines the criteria that we both find satisfactory. Right now, the Park Board is refusing to work with us on this – they have said that they aren’t open to any changes to this language. That’s not good enough.

You can see the entire section and our proposed changes highlighted in red here.

The Three Changes We Are Requesting Are Reasonable and Simple

We are requesting three reasonable and simple changes to the JOA through the appendices. We are not asking the Park Board to change the body of the JOA.

Park Board staff is refusing to even talk with us about how we could find a way – together – to accommodate these changes. We are willing to work with Park Board staff to find mutually acceptable language – but they say they are not interested in discussing further changes.

Why is Park Board staff refusing to work with us to get this done? Why is Park Board staff drawing a line in the sand when we are so close to getting a signed Joint Operating Agreement that we can all accept? Where is the leadership Commissioners promised us?

One Word

In Appendix Clause 15 (JOA Section 14.3), we want to change one word – from “or” to “and” – this seems pretty straightforward to us. Park Board staff refuses to even discuss this. What is going on? Why are they refusing this simple change? You can see the entire section and our proposed change highlighted in red here.

Clarity

The only other changes we require before we can sign the JOA are two that clarify the language of the how, when and why the Park Board could terminate the agreement or deny a CCA access to a new portion of the facility. The existing language is vague and does not provide any guidelines for CCAs to follow. They could be at risk of being terminated, yet have no idea they are doing anything wrong.

JOA Section 20.1 currently states that if there is to be a new addition to the facility, the Park Board may deny a CCA access to this area, even if the CCA currently has programming that is consistent with that offered in the new space. Section 20.3 states that if a community centre is replaced, the Park Board may terminate the JOA and not allow the CCA to jointly operate the new facility.

For example, when a new child care facility is set to be established in a community and the CCA is already effectively and successfully offering child care and wants to expand into the new facility, it could be denied for undefined reasons that are currently stated as “reasonable concerns” and that these “concerns” could have occurred prior to this JOA being signed (the Park Board could go back years or decades). Another example of this is in the case of a CCA that is due for an upgrade to their community centre. A new facility could mean that the JOA could be terminated by the Park Board and the CCA could be pushed out of their role in jointly operating the new community centre with the Park Board – because they got a new building (which some CCAs have spent years and even decades fundraising for – and would contribute financially to the new facility by purchasing equipment, furniture, etc.).

As it is written, a CCA would not necessarily know or find out, until it was too late, what the Park Board considered “reasonable concerns” or if it is considered to be in “sustained breach.” We just want criteria/specifics around this process – which is reasonable to request. You can see the entire section and our proposed changes highlighted in red here.

Defined

We agree that this section needs to be in the JOA to ensure that CCAs are effective and meet operational standards. We just want the standards in this new contract that we are expected to sign to be clear and defined so we can continue to meet them – as we have done for decades!

Why Are Commissioners Allowing Staff to Derail This Process?

We are so close to having a JOA! Let’s get this done! These are straightforward and necessary changes. They are all that we need in order to recommend to our respective boards that they sign this agreement.

Come on Park Board Commissioners – why are you allowing staff to derail the JOA process when we are so close to being able to sign?

There Is Still Work to Be Done Before We Can Sign the JOA

Readers of this blog know that our negotiation of the Joint Operating Agreement (JOA) with the Park Board has been long, difficult and incredibly frustrating. In fact, it is interesting to point out that throughout the close to two-year process, the Park Board told us not to call this a “negotiation.” That it wasn’t. They called it a “consultative process.” From our perspective, it has never met the criteria required to be considered a consultation or consultative process.

Whatever you want to call it, this is a negotiation. The CCAs have given up elements in this agreement in response to the Park Board’s push back and the Park Board has agreed to include or remove sections that the CCAs have clearly communicated as priorities. That’s a negotiation of two partners working out an important agreement.

It is concerning that the messaging coming out by the Park Board is that out of 19 CCAs being offered a JOA, they are reporting that 11 have signed – and that seven are close to signing. That math doesn’t add up. We’re not sure what they mean because if you do the math, there are three of us (Hastings Community Association, Kerrisdale Community Centre Society and Killarney Community Centre Society) continuing to work together, taking a leadership position, and pushing back on the Park Board about important changes that must be made.

If 11 have signed and seven are close to signing, that is a total of 18 out of 19… Since three of us are not close to signing until some changes are made, the math they are putting out there doesn’t add up.

It is important to remember that “close to signing” does not mean “signed.” We talk to other CCAs regularly – those who have signed and those who have not. And they are following our negotiations with the Park Board because if we get additional changes in our agreement, they will have the option to have those changes included in theirs – even if they have already signed.

We went into January cautiously, hopeful that we could get a JOA that we felt was acceptable enough to take to our respective boards and recommend signing it. Each of our communities and our boards of directors gave us a mandate to get a JOA that will work for our respective communities – not a JOA that just works for the Park Board. And we continue to follow their direction.

While we continue to work towards getting a JOA that we can live with, we are feeling less hopeful at this stage of the negotiation process. We are asking for a change in the document which is crucial to our CCAs that the Park Board lawyers and staff are flatly refusing to make and they are not providing any rational reason as to why they won’t make it, except to say: “We disagree with you.” That’s not good enough.

Through our legal counsel, we have just re-submitted our requirements to the Park Board. We have a rationale and reasons for why these revisions need to be done. We’d like to hear why the Park Board lawyers and staff are flatly refusing to work with us to find a solution.

It is time for Commissioners to step back in and provide the leadership that they continue to tell the people of Vancouver that they bring to their roles.

In an election year, you would think that Park Board Commissioners would want to showcase their value to the diverse and unique communities of this great city.

CCA Response to Park Board

We responded to the Park Board on January 16, 2018 regarding the important changes that are still needed in the Joint Operating Agreement appendices. Please click to see the:

We will keep you posted on the Park Board’s response. 

New Year, New JOA? We Hope So

After thousands of hours of negotiation, through meetings between CCAs and with CCAs and Park Board staff and lawyers, facilitated (by Park Board) workshops – as well as CCA working groups, meetings, review of documents, research and providing our input – we feel like we are closer than we have ever been to having a Joint Operating Agreement (JOA) that will work for the Park Board and our CCAs. As many of you know, this has not been easy. If we are able to make the one important change to the appendices and work out our more straightforward location-specific appendices, we can take this agreement to our respective board members for a vote.

We’re Still Standing… and Fighting

Kerrisdale Community Centre Society, Killarney Community Centre Society and Hastings Community Association have taken the lead on pushing back against the Park Board over the past several months. Each of us has a mandate from our community to get a JOA that works and we take that responsibility seriously. And, of course, there is the fact that the three of us are a part of a court injunction, which provides us with an additional layer of protection because we can’t be evicted as a result of this injunction.

Taking the lead is something that each of our CCAs is accustomed to doing. Many of the CCAs – even those who have signed or agreed to sign – are watching what is happening between us and the Park Board closely. You see, any revisions to the appendices that are done for us can be applied to their agreement as well, if they want it.

Community Engagement and Support Is Key

As we turn what we hope will be the final corner in this long and tough battle to get a JOA that respects the diverse communities and CCAs of Vancouver, we want to acknowledge how important our communities have been in this fight. Your willingness to support us – by coming to meetings, by communicating with Park Board Commissioners, by sending e-mails, tweets and calling the Park Board – gave us the energy and resolve to keep pushing forward on behalf of our communities.

There were many days when we were down or discouraged or just flat out frustrated at what we believe was an ineffective, unbalanced negotiation process – and your support re-energized us. Whether it was a passing comment at our community centre from a member, someone giving us a call, or showing up when we needed you – we want you to know how much that meant. While some might call our three CCAs “a pain in the neck,” we always felt that we were on the side of what was right for our communities – and that came from you. You gave us the push we needed to keep fighting – and we still are. There is one more change we need to see before we can move to the more straightforward elements specific to each of our community centres. And because of your continued support, we know that we have the strength to push until we get that language changed. Thank you for everything. We are so proud of how each of our communities stepped up, leaned in, and showed up to support the CCAs.

We will keep you posted on the Park Board’s response to our required change. We hope to hear from them this week.

Joint Operating Agreement Update

Happy New Year! We hope that 2018 brings much happiness and success to all of our blog readers, supporters and community centre members. We also hope that it brings a Joint Operating Agreement (JOA) that works for the Park Board and our diverse Vancouver communities.

As we come into 2018, we are continuing to negotiate with the Park Board about the JOA. We have one large outstanding issue that needs to be resolved – and then the focus will be on each of our site-specific appendices, which we believe will be straightforward in nature. We are hopeful that the one outstanding issue will be addressed by the Park Board within the next week or so and that we can then move on to the more “operational” specifics for each of our community centres.

November and December were busy for us. We – along with our legal counsel – met with lawyers from the Park Board and were in regular communication with them and staff.

We submitted a letter to Donnie Rosa, Director of Recreation for the Park Board, outlining a key point that needs to be addressed – and once it is, we will be closer than we have ever been to getting an agreement that we are satisfied with. You can read the letter here: Letter to Donnie Rosa – Dec 22-2017.

In essence, the status is: We continue to work on sections of Appendix C in collaboration/negotiation with the Park Board. We have concerns with the language in sections 17 and 18 of Appendix C regarding the Park Board’s ability to terminate a Community Centre Association (CCA) upon expansion or replacement of a facility. Currently, it says that if the Park Board has “reasonable concern” as to whether the association can run a community centre, there is the ability to terminate the agreement. What “reasonable” means in this context is not defined – and the decision by the Park Board could be totally subjective. This needs to be defined – and to be objective.

This might seem like a small thing – but it’s not. It is crucial that “reasonable concern” be clearly defined and agreed upon by the CCAs and the Park Board. Without a clear definition and objective language, it provides the Park Board with the ability to terminate a CCA without having to justify it. And while we don’t expect that this would happen – in protecting the interests of our members – it can’t be left as an option.

We know that staff and commissioners want to get an agreement in place. We do too. This last change to the appendices is the final ask of the group. If the Park Board agrees to it, we will be very close to getting a JOA that we feel will work for us.

We look forward to getting this done, to celebrating a new JOA with Park Board, and to turning our attention back to our communities!

Why We Continue to Fight for a JOA That Works for CCAs

As many of you know, some Community Centre Associations have chosen to sign the Joint Operating Agreement (JOA) with the Park Board. We have received several questions about how we feel about this. We’d like to tell you exactly how we feel.

Each CCA is different and serves a unique community. Each CCA board is made up of engaged community members, and the decision to sign or not sign is made because the board members feel that their decision is in the best interest of their community, their community centre and their CCA. Some community centres have decided to sign the agreement while we continue to negotiate with the Park Board to address the six serious issues in the JOA. That is their right – and we respect their decision.

In addition, many of these CCAs that have signed the JOA don’t have the layer of security that we do – which is because of a court injunction stemming from a 2013 lawsuit was filed against the Park Board. The injunction says that the CCAs involved in the lawsuit (which includes Hastings Community Association, Kerrisdale Community Centre Society and Killarney Community Centre Society) can’t be evicted from our community centres. This provides us with the ability to push back harder to get the Park Board to address all of the issues that have been identified in the JOA (and which the Park Board has acknowledged).

At this moment, we believe that the Park Board is acting in good faith and – like us – they want to get through this process and get a JOA that we can recommend to our boards to sign. We want to create a positive outcome for what has been a long, difficult and drawn-out process.

Currently, the court injunction and the lawsuit sit quietly in the background. It isn’t a part of the negotiation process – and it shouldn’t be right now. This phase of the negotiation of the JOA is about addressing each of the six serious issues in the document through the appendices – and that is what we are doing.

Having said that, the injunction means that the three of our CCAs have the ability to hold the Park Board accountable and to continue in our higher-profile role to push for the best possible outcome for the JOA. What we are working towards will benefit other CCAs – even those who have signed. The Park Board has publicly stated that changes made to one CCA’s appendices can be made to another CCA’s, if the CCA requests it. We speak with other CCA presidents, board members and representatives on a regular basis – they are closely monitoring our negotiations with the Park Board. They support us and they care about how these serious issues are addressed in the appendices.

What we can tell you – is that three of us aren’t going anywhere until we get a JOA that works for our diverse communities, that addresses the six serious issues in the agreement to the satisfaction of all involved, and that we can recommend to our respective boards to sign.

We are cautiously hopeful – and will keep you posted.